The MirrorARCHIVES: Feb 26 - Mar 04 2009 Vol. 24 No. 36  



The other Oscars

Mirror readers vote on the issues that
really matter in the 13th Annual
Alternative Academy Awards


TUNEFUL TALE: Slumdog Millionaire

Until the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences finally comes to its senses and starts giving out that Best Kiss Oscar, there’ll always be room for other perspectives on the cinematic achievements of the year. To that end, we polled our readers on 2008’s most beautiful babes (of both genders), most awesome-est action scenes, and which movies and performances just plain blew.

The illuminating results are below—the envelope, please…

MOVIE MOST OVERLOOKED BY THE ACADEMY

While Hollywood rewarded the late Heath Ledger’s playful, creepy performance as the Joker, readers apparently felt the movie itself deserved some of that shine as well. Jonathan Demme’s very deserving wedding-set dramedy also got love.

30% The Dark Knight
23% Rachel Getting Married
16% Wendy & Lucy
16% Vicky Cristina Barcelona
15% Gran Torino

MOST OVERLOOKED PERFORMANCE

Clint’s growly, self-directed performance in his latest—for which he really pulled out all the stops, even singing the end-credits song—gets recognized by Mirror readers, with Jean-Claude Van Damme’s soul-baring act as himself in second.

24% Clint Eastwood, Gran Torino
23% Jean-Claude Van Damme, JCVD
20% Dev Patel, Slumdog Millionaire
18% Sally Hawkins, Happy-Go-Lucky
15% Wall•E, Wall•E

BEST SOUNDTRACK

Hard to top Slumdog’s zeitgeist-nailing A.R. Rahman/M.I.A. combo, though ABBA’s unimpeachable pop hooks were enough to bring Mamma Mia! in as a close second. But not even LCD Soundsystem and MGMT could get anyone to care about 21.

35% Slumdog Millionaire
33% Mamma Mia!
20% Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist
9% Shine a Light
3% 21

BEST MALE BOD

Bat-stud Christian Bale just edges past Bond babe Daniel Craig in this year’s battle of the screen studs—though don’t count out Mickey Rourke, who proved this year he still has the goods.

27% Christian Bale, The Dark Knight
26% Daniel Craig, Quantum of Solace
23% Mickey Rourke, The Wrestler
13% Leonardo DiCaprio, Revolutionary Road
11% Robert Pattinson, Twilight

BEST FEMALE BOD

Like her Wrestler co-star Mickey Rourke, Marisa Tomei proves that if you’ve still got it, it’s worth it to flaunt it—Mirror readers at the very least will appreciate the effort.

33% Marisa Tomei, The Wrestler
29% Olga Kurylenko, Quantum of Solace
18% Mila Kunis, Forgetting Sarah Marshall
11% Anna Faris, The House
Bunny 9% Kat Dennings, Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist

WORST PERFORMANCE

Mike Myers’ bizarre faux-Indian shtick as The Love Guru wins this one in a landslide, with double the votes of Mark Wahlberg’s hapless, plant-conversing M. Night Shyamalan protagonist.

42% Mike Myers, The Love Guru
21% Mark Wahlberg, The Happening
16% Burt Reynolds, In the Name of the King: A Dungeon Siege Tale
14% Hayden Christensen, Jumper
7% Al Pacino, 88 Minutes

BEST ACTION SCENES

Hard to argue with the choice of The Dark Knight’s IMAX-enhanced blockbuster set pieces, which also benefited from minimal CGI effects—unlike the big loser, The Incredible Hulk, which was practically a cartoon.

52% The Dark Knight
25% Iron Man
10% Rambo
8% Mongol
5% The Incredible Hulk

MOST OVERRATED

Lots to choose from in a year widely considered pretty lackluster, but the 12-Oscar-nominated Benjamin Button, which nobody seemed to really like, handily takes the prize. It’s also worth noting the Dark Knight backlash, a movie which our readers seem to think is both overlooked and overrated.

37% The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
31% The Dark Knight
15% Revolutionary Road
9% The Reader
8% In Bruges

FUNNIEST FILM

Lots to choose from this year, but the Ben Stiller/Robert Downey, Jr./Jack Black/Steve Coogan supergroup behind Tropic Thunder won voters’ favour, with two Judd Apatow offerings in second and third.

29% Tropic Thunder
26% Pineapple Express
22% Forgetting Sarah Marshall
17% You Don’t Mess With the Zohan
6% Step Brothers

BEST SEX SCENE

Though it’s more suggested than shown, who could resist that threesome? I mean, really. You can keep your naked Nazi Kate Winslet.

46% Threesome with Scarlett Johansson,
Penélope Cruz and Javier Bardem,
Vicky Cristina Barcelona
18% Bathtub frolic, The Reader
17% Take your pick, Young People Fucking
10% Russell Brand and Kristen Bell go nuts,
Forgetting Sarah Marshall
9% Zack and Miri make a porno,
Zack and Miri Make a Porno

TURKEY OF THE YEAR

Canada loves to eat its own, and no more in the case of Mike Myers, who got both the Worst Performance dishonour and this for his universally loathed Love Guru.

52% The Love Guru
18% Meet the Spartans
11% Fool’s Gold
10% The Happening
9% Righteous Kill

AND NOW FOR THE REAL OSCARS…

Congratulations to Vicky Parisella, randomly selected from the pool of several readers to guess every one of the major Oscar categories (Best Picture, Best Director and all the acting categories) correctly. She wins a double pass for every Sony Pictures Releasing film to open through the end of December 2009—not bad! Coming in second place is Diane Voyer, who gets 10 DVDs from Alliance Vivafilm, and third goes to David Cyr, who gets a $100 gift certificate to Le Ryad. Good work, everyone, and thanks to our sponsors.

But the real lucky (in a manner of speaking) contestant, is Patrick Pomerleau, randomly selected from the few who got every category wrong. Patrick, step up and receive your Montreal Mirror Alternative Academy Awards Lucky Loser Booby Prize Bonanza! You receive a DVD PRIZE PACK that includes Céline: Her Life Story (“If music touches your soul, you’ll love…”), Matthew McConaughey’s Surfer, Dude (“Bud, Beaches & Babes… now all he needs are waves”), Wizards of Waverly Place (“Supernaturally Stylin’”), the Air Bud Dogtastic Double Feature set (containing the original and Seventh Inning Fetch), Screamers: The Hunting (“A mind-shattering sequel”) and Disney’s The Secret of the Magic Gourd (“Includes English, Mandarin & Cantonese Language Tracks”).

Ballots compiled by Jeffrey Malecki, commentary by Mark Slutsky

THE OSCAR NOMINATED SHORT
FILMS 2009 OPENS AT THE CINÉMA
DU PARC THIS FRIDAY, FEB. 20

MIRROR ARCHIVES » Feb 26 Mar 04 2009: INSIDE - COVER | ARCHIVES INDEX | CURRENT ISSUE
© Communications Gratte-Ciel Ltée 2009